Background and context
Global context
Concerns and consequences
The interactive hotspot map above provides an exploration of the historical evolution of birth settings and practices across different regions worldwide. The prevailing global trend has been the movement of childbirth from home settings to hospitals, a shift that has received criticism for its potential impact on increasing risk orientation and medicalisation of childbirth (Goldkuhl et al., 2022).
In the United States, hospital births account for the vast majority (98.4%) of deliveries, with only 0.99 percent occurring at home and 0.52 percent in freestanding birth centres (MacDorman & Declercq, 2018). Similarly, in the UK, before the pandemic, over 80% of women gave birth in obstetric units, 14% in birth centres, and 2.5% chose home birth (Mohammad, 2023). These statistics do not align with the evidence suggesting that home and midwifery-led settings lead to improved maternal outcomes, increased maternal satisfaction, and more efficient resource utilisation.
Hospitals have increasingly adopted a medicalised perspective on labour, perceiving pregnancy and birth primarily as a medical condition to be monitored, measured, and treated rather than as a natural process (Davis-Floyd, 2001). Research indicates that women who give birth in hospital settings tend to adopt a more passive role, while those in birth centres or at home experience a greater sense of control and actively participate in their birthing experience (Mondy et al., 2016).
A midwifery-led model of care prioritises supporting the physiological processes of childbirth and avoiding unnecessary interventions. This approach fosters a safe and empowering birth environment that encourages women’s innate ability to give birth while respecting their needs and preserving their dignity (Berg et al., 2012; Edmonds et al., 2020).
Studies highlight that a positive childbirth experience for women encompasses delivering a healthy baby in a safe environment, receiving supportive and compassionate care from healthcare providers, and maintaining a sense of control throughout the birthing process (Downe et al., 2018).
Overall, the global landscape of birth settings underscores the importance of aligning birthing practices with women’s preferences, promoting evidence-based care, and ensuring that women have access to safe and satisfying birthing experiences.

